The struggles of one Newar community to hold on to its traditions
The Guthi bill that was tabled by Minister of Land Management, Cooperatives and Poverty Alleviation Padma Kumari Aryal was met with strong protests, especially by the Newars of Kathmandu. The bill proposed to regulate all religious sites, nationalize both private and public guthis, and ‘better manage’ guthi lands and assets.
Following the protests, the government withdrew the bill on June 18. Still, a peaceful demonstration was staged on June 19 at Maitighar Mandala, demanding that the government scrap the bill altogether. Nardevi Guthi estimates more than 100,000 people from different ethnic groups of Nepal took part.
Among the many castes within the Newar community is Jyapu. Jyapus (“competent workers” in Newari) have rich traditions. Their pottery work and unique traditional music enrich the Newari culture. If the Guthi Bill was endorsed, Jyapu guthi operators worry, it could have vastly altered their way of life that they have preserved for generations.
Satya Narayan Dangol, 65, president of Nardevi Guthi and vice-president of Jyapu Maha Guthi, says that one reason guthis were formed, centuries ago, was to manage land used for religious and cultural purposes. Different guthis serve different purposes. There are 60 guthis in Kathmandu under Jyapu Maha Guthi, with around 200,000 members. Even under these 60 guthis, there are smaller guthis that handle different tasks. For example, under Nardevi Guthi, there are 24 guthis that have direct contact with the government for the celebration of 24 compulsory Jyapu festivals. Similarly, there are other Jyapu guthis outside Kathmandu.
Each Jyapu guthi has a unique responsibility during the celebration of festivals, including organizing bhoj (banquets). Dangol gives an example of how the festivals would have been affected had the bill passed. Jyapu Maha Guthi organizes ‘Devi Nach’ in Nardevi Chowk in Kathmandu during Ghode Jatra. This dance is performed for 36 hours straight, attracting locals and foreigners alike. The next day, Jyapus pull a chariot, taking it around the core areas of Kathmandu valley to celebrate Paanchare (Nardevi Jatra). “How would the government have managed the logistics on such a scale?” Dangol asks.
"How would the government have managed the logistics on such a scale?"
Satya Narayan Dangol President of Nardevi Guthi
Don’t need no permission
Then there are small Jyapu guthis whose only work is to provide drinking water to visitors during Rato Machhindranath Jatra in Patan. Had the Guthi bill passed, Dangol wonders if the government would have provided contractual work to serve drinks during festivals, as he is certain small guthis would have dissolved. Moreover, assets such as chariots, idols, and jewelry used in various cultural dances would have all belonged to the government. And guthi operators would have required permission to use them, which Dangol says would be unacceptable.
Like other Newar communities, Jyapus also have their own Kuladevata, Clan God, which is passed down generations and is usually owned by guthis. Dangol says that it is infuriating to think that his pious Clan God would also have belonged to the government. “I would have to seek the government’s permission to pray to my own Clan God. This reminds me of what Mao Tse-tung did in China,” he says, in what had become a common refrain of Newari protestors. Chairman Mao had launched a destructive campaign against the ‘Four Olds’—old customs, cultures, habits, and ideas—as part of the Cultural Revolution in the 1960s.
Ashish Maharjan, 26, who also hails from the Jyapu community, says, “The government has no right to touch our holy and treasured rituals and idols.”
Instead of preserving culture, Dangol says the government had been bent on trying to control guthi lands and assets. He adds that funds for the “Bahra Barse Devi Naach”, which takes place every 12 years and is organized by Nardevi Guthi, used to come directly from the Finance Ministry. He points out Jyapu Maha Guthi received Rs 200,000 for the last time in 1969 through King Mahendra. Since then, the government has refused to provide money and so the guthi operators are managing funds themselves.
Guthis, such as Sana-Guthi, Raj-Guthi, Si-Guthi, which play a vital role in keeping community spirit alive by organizing communal meals and providing solace to families who have lost a member, would have also been affected.
Suggest, don’t suppress
Dangol says Si-Guthi currently has Rs 4 million, collected by organizing a biannual bhoj. This bhoj takes place on the day of Yomari Punhi (on full-moon day in November/December) and then exactly six months later. Members have to pay a minimum amount to organize the bhoj, and any excess money they contribute goes to the Si-Guthi fund. The money is later used when someone from a family belonging to the guthi dies. Guthi operators visit the house and manage all death rituals. Dangol wonders if the government officials would have been willing to visit the families of the deceased and how they would have managed the intricate rituals.
Spokesperson of Ministry of Land Management, Cooperatives and Poverty Alleviation Janak Raj Joshi says the bill was tabled to make guthis more systematic and organized. He adds that given the widespread concern over the bill, the ministry, in any case, would take into account everyone’s concerns and interests before moving forward.
Dangol says if the ministry wanted to make guthis more systematic, it could have offered suggestions to existing guthis “instead of trying to replace a system that has been in place for generations”. The nature of guthis in Janakpur or Dang should not, he adds, influence the government’s decision on managing guthis in other regions of the country. He thinks the bill would have been more appropriate for a place like Dang, where landless peasants have worked the lands of others for generations.
But that’s not the case in Kathmandu. “Jyapus in Kathmandu have donated a lot of lands to guthis. For example, my forefathers gave some of their land to their children and the rest to various guthis,” says Dangol. He thinks that the government should solicit advice from the local governments before proposing a similar bill in the future and that each province should have a different set of laws governing guthis.
Had the bill passed, Dangol says, it would have affected not just Newar guthis, but also those of other ethnicities. Dangol adds that guthi operators should reflect on why guthis were formed in the first place and try harder to meet those needs.
LGBT community marks Pride Month with hope and fear
The month of June is internationally recognized as the LGBT Pride Month. The month-long celebrations are aimed at fighting for equal rights, increasing social visibility, and celebrating sexual and gender diversity. June was selected as the Pride Month to commemorate the Stonewall riots of 28 June, 1969, following a police raid in Stonewall Inn, a gay bar in New York City. These riots would became an impetus for Pride marches.
In Nepal, no such declaration of Pride Month has been made and queer events have only recently started garnering social attention. Nepal nonetheless has a vibrant queer community. Culturally, cross-dressing and transgender people have always existed in Nepal. Transgender women (called ‘metis’ in Nepali) were traditionally believed to ward off evil spirits at wedding ceremonies or at childbirth. Among the Gurungs, there is a tradition of men dressing up as women and performing the maaruni dance.
In 2007 Nepal government legalized homosexuality, cross-dressing and began allowing a third gender option on documents. And yet, twelve years on, discussion on gender and sexual diversity is not only scarce but also prejudiced.
In order to change this state of affairs, a few organizations host rallies for LGBT awareness and social inclusion. The Blue Diamond Society (BDS) first organized the Gaijatra International Pride Parade in Nepal for Nepali LGBT community in 2010. Held in Kathmandu, it also saw participation from various countries and was led by Sunil Babu Pant, the first openly gay member of the Nepali parliament.
Bhakti Shah, an LGBT activist with the BDS, says, “This march is aimed at providing a comfortable climate for any LGBT individual to open up, dress any way they like and to celebrate themselves.” The rally has also attracted some criticism because it is observed on Gaijatra, the day people from the Newar community remember the dead by having young boys dress up as cows. This mingling of the religious and the ‘profane’ has sometimes resulted in open conflict.
As a result of this criticism, other organizations have started hosting their pride marches at other times of the year. For instance, a Queer MOGAI Pride Parade is held in Nepal on 5 May—MOGAI stands for Marginalized Orientation (sexual/romantic), Gender alignments (identity/ expressions) and Intersex bodily variations. Another pride parade was organized by Mitini Nepal alongside the international One Billion Rising campaign in Kathmandu on 14 February this year. In addition, this year the Queer Youth Group organized a Queer/MOGAI/LBTI women pride to encourage women from diverse sexual orientations, as well as intersex and transgender women to come out.
The Blue Diamond Society’s Shah wants the government to formulate and implement inclusive policies that give equal rights to the marginalized LGBT community.
After homosexuality was decriminalized in Nepal in 2007, the 2015 constitution was also praised for its inclusiveness and LGBT-friendliness. Article 12 states that people have the right to citizenship with their preferred gender. Article 18 prohibits any discrimination based on sex, gender or sexual orientation. It also makes provisions for special protections provided by law and gender neutral terms instead of previously used ‘male’ or ‘female’. The constitution allows gender and sexual minorities the right to access public services.
However, as Shah points out, the new Nepali Civil Code that came into effect in August 2018 identifies marriage only between opposite sexes. In addition, it states that no one should marry or help someone marry with a lie or lies based on the ambiguity of sexual organs or lack thereof. Many activists have spoken against this and deemed the code unconstitutional.
The laws are also not accommodating to non-cisgender people as it might be to cisgender people (whose sense of personal identity and gender corresponds with their birth sex). Activist Rukshana Kapali, a transgender woman, was denied admission into Tribhuvan University for her Masters’ degree. Kapali had different names in her School Leaving Certificate and +2 certificates, which were prepared before and after her coming out respectively. Shortly, the hashtag ‘#TransExclusionistTU’ was trending on Twitter.
Such difficulties of queer people is exactly why Kapali stresses the need for Pride celebrations. “Pride makes us visible. While it is a moment for queer people to have fun, it is also an opportunity for our voices to be heard. At least people get to know that we exist. ”
Social acceptance is still problematic. Kapali says most people of the older generation find it hard to understand queer identities. Even among the younger generation, she says, bullying of queer people is rampant. “However, I am hopeful that things will change with increased visibility, social awareness and advocacy for queer acceptance and equality.”
Misery-filled retelling of an epic
The first thematic production of Karman, “Klesha: Ananta Pida Ko Jal”, tries to unearth the reasons for our misery and tribulations. The play, based on rural Nepal, has chapters of the epic creation of sage Valmiki, “The Ramayana”, but without its religious aspects.
Writer Pratikshya Kattel tries to explore the multiple ways Ramayana fascinated her. She says she used to ask herself: What caused the bloodshed? Why did Lord Ram and Ravan play the game of life and death? Kattel arrives at the conclusion that the only reason for this hostility, and in fact all hostilities in the world, is misery.
The set features a typical Nepali terrain and the characters dress in daura suruwal and guniyo cholo. The play starts as a group of characters descend on the stage with flaming torches in their hands, accompanied by the sound of live music.
The villagers are livid with their Mahanta Devdatta (Pratik Maratha) for his unjust decision against their common daughter Kaanchi (Ruju Sharma). Kaanchi is a young Nepali girl who falls in love with Devdatta’s brother Anuj. A section of the play displays their love story; their story ends on a sad note as Anuj deceives her when she gets pregnant.
In fact, Anuj beats Kaanchi so badly that she miscarries. The pivotal character of Kaanchi does not have many dialogues and is yet able to amply express her agony through her phenomenal acting skills and expressions. Plotting on a revenge against Devdatta and his family, the villagers kidnap Bhumi (Surakshya Panta), Devdatta’s wife, who is completely unaware of what is happening around her.
The play also comprises of humorous characters like Balram (Swapnil Ghimire), who becomes the veritable Hanuman from the epic as he acts as a messenger for Devdatta and Bhumi. Vidhan (Toofan Thapa) and Jitbahadur ( Jivannath Paudel) time and again light up the mood of the auditorium.
Klesha is all about the agony of Kaanchi, the selfishness of Anuj, the ignorance of Devdatta, the innocence of Bhumi, the fury of Rudra, and the joyfulness of Balram. In the process of taking revenge, the villagers get trapped into a vicious circle. The 1h 45mins play at Mandala Theatre runs till June 23, at 5:30 pm, every day except Mondays.
An ode to their fans
‘Sabin Rai and the Pharaoh’ released their first studio album “Dhanyabad” this week at Tangalwood and the band’s fans can’t thank them enough for the music they’re distributing for free through Facebook and other digital music platforms.
The seven-track album is an ode to the band’s fans and supporters, the band says, and it has been made completely free to reach out more to their audience. “We do not want to reserve the album and wait for our listeners to buy it,” says Binod Lama Tamang, drummer and manager of Sabin Rai and the Pharaoh.
“We want our fans from all over the world to listen to it right now.” The band took over a year to complete the album amid their packed schedule of shows and tours, Binod informs, and all the recording, mixing and mastering was done locally in multiple studios.
In this album, Sabin Rai’s music has advanced technically and it completes his metamorphosis from a pop icon to a rock star. With accomplished musicians in the Pharaoh, Sabin’s style of singing and performing has evolved in virtuosity and the audience can feel the power he packs with the band in his recordings as well as live performances.
Comprising the Pharaoh are John Shrestha on guitars and Jeevan Lama on bass—both good students and educators of music—along with the versatile Nikesh KC on guitars, accompanied by Binod, who is one of the steadiest hands on the drums in the current music scene.
Just two and a half years of playing together as a band has brought them unprecedented success with the band already touring all over Nepal and extensively in India, UK, Bahrain and Australia. “This is the best lineup I have ever performed with,” Sabin tells APEX.
“The guys are extremely talented and supportive. We understand each other perfectly and hence have been able to give our very best in this album”.