CESIF organizes round table discussion on Nepal-China Bilateral Relations

Center for Social Inclusion and Federalism (CESIF) organized a round table discussion on Nepal-China Bilateral Relations, reflecting on the Prime Minister’s visit to India from September 23-30, 2023.

The discourse was held at Basera Boutique Hotel on December 12, 2023 and brought together distinguished parliamentarians, experts, journalists, former bureaucrats and diplomats.

Raj Kishor Yadav, Chairperson of the International Relations and Tourism Committee at the House of Representative, was the chief guest speaker of the program, reads a statement issued by Center for Social Inclusion & Federalism.

Similarly, Tsering Lhamu Lama (Tamang) and Sishir Khanal, both members of the International Relations and Tourism Committee, Dr Minendra Rijal, former Defense Minister of Nepal and Central Working Committee member of the Nepali Congress and Ambassador Madhu Raman Acharya, former Foreign Secretary of Nepal and Permanent Representative of Nepal to the United Nations, New York, were the prominent speakers.

The Executive Chair of CESIF, Ambassador Vijay Kant Karna reflected in his opening remarks that the Prime Minister’s visit was an important event but had limitations. Although a 12-point agreement was announced in the joint statement of both prime ministers, earlier agreements are yet to be followed up by both countries. “The visit was unsuccessful in attracting significant Chinese investments in infrastructure development,” Ambassador Karna said.

The dialogue brought together diverse views from the parliamentarians and participants.

Raj Kishor Yadav expressed the necessity to maintain a balanced relationship between China and other world and regional powers.

He further noted that our foreign policy must avoid “fear psychosis” when dealing with foreign countries.

Similarly, Tsering Lhamu Lama (Tamang) expressed the importance of opening border points between Nepal and China. Lama representing Karnali Province, reminded that five of the border points are in Karnali, which can hugely benefit the economy of the province. Lama concluded that the visit was successful as it was also able to secure the agreement with China to build a road to Man Sarovar from Nepal, according to the statement.

Likewise, Sishir Khanal noted that the Prime Minister’s visit was not clear enough in its objectives. He further said that the visit did not make any significant contributions towards the relationship between Nepal and China, including the BRI agreement and the border points. He raised a concern as Nepal formally accepted the “One China Principle,” moving on from the “One China Policy”.

Dr Minendra Rijal said that the joint communique has a language that is rather imposing on Nepal. He expressed concerns about debts Nepal is taking from China, including the amount for the Pokhara International Airport.

Moreover, Ambassador Madhu Raman Acharya pointed out that there was no substance in the agreement except the transmission line between Kerung and Rashuwagadhi. He said that among the seventy agreements since the former PM KP Sharma Oli visit to China, only a few are being implemented. He also expressed concerns about the joint communique’s language against Taiwan’s independence.

Overall, the participants were united in expressing that the agreements signed during this and previous visits have not been successfully implemented. There was also a concern that official agreements to implement BRI in Nepal are not yet public, which is allowing China to shift goalposts.

The participants opined that Nepal needs to understand China's strategic concerns better and express Nepalese interests specifically with China.