How a severe doctor shortage is crippling healthcare in Karnali
Falling ill in Karnali Province means fighting a war on two fronts: against physical disease, and against formidable geography combined with institutional neglect. While healthcare institutions do exist on paper, doctors are nowhere to be found. Tall, multi-million-rupee facilities equipped with modern medical technology stand across the province—from remote district facilities to the provincial capital—yet most function as little more than empty shells.
At the 300-bed Provincial Hospital in Birendranagar, Surkhet, the courtyard is packed with patients every morning, yet the facility lacks sufficient specialist doctors to treat them. Routine check-ups frequently require a two-day wait. Uma Rawal, who traveled to Surkhet from Mugu seeking treatment for severe abdominal pain, recounted that she was forced to leave her home district because no doctors were available. Upon arriving at the provincial hospital early in the morning, she faced massive queues just to receive a token. It took her two full days for a basic consultation, only to be told that obtaining routine blood and urine test results would require another three days of waiting.
Rawal's ordeal is shared by thousands of patients arriving in Surkhet from across Karnali’s ten districts. Data from Karnali Province’s Ministry of Social Development paints a grim picture, revealing that nearly 76 percent of specialist doctor positions in major government hospitals remain vacant. Out of 95 sanctioned specialist positions across the province, only 23 are filled, leaving 72 posts completely empty.
The situation is even direr in remote and mountainous districts such as Jajarkot, Dolpa, Humla, Mugu, Kalikot, and Dailekh, where not a single specialist doctor is currently on duty, forcing citizens with complex medical conditions to seek care far outside their home regions.
Even the Provincial Hospital in Surkhet, the primary referral center for the entire province, operates far below its designated capacity. According to Anita Gyawali, Information Officer and Under Secretary at the hospital, only 20 of its 48 sanctioned specialist doctor positions are currently filled, leaving 28 vacant.
This chronic shortage heavily impacts cardiology, neurology, gynecology, radiology, pathology, and general medicine. The hospital is meant to manage 150 beds with provincial funding, but high patient volume has forced the Hospital Development Committee to run an extra 150 beds, operating a 350-bed facility in practice.
Out of a total sanctioned setup of 540 positions across all staff tiers, 100 remain unfilled, leaving the remaining medical staff completely overwhelmed.
As a result of this crisis, district hospitals across Karnali have largely devolved into mere referral centers. In Salyan District Hospital, surgical services were completely suspended due to a lack of doctors.
Dr. Arjun Kumar Budha, Chief of the Health Service Office in Salyan, explained that patients requiring low-cost local surgeries, as well as pregnant women facing life-threatening complications, are now forced to travel two to three hours by car to facilities in Dang, Nepalgunj, or Surkhet. The hospital has seven sanctioned specialist posts, but only one is filled. Similarly, at Kalikot District Hospital, only one ninth-level doctor, Dr. Ratnabir Sunar, is currently working, while all four specialist positions remain vacant.
This pattern of abandonment extends throughout the rest of the province. Jajarkot, Dailekh, Humla, Mugu, and Dolpa district hospitals each have four to seven sanctioned specialist posts, yet every single one of these positions remains vacant. In Mehalkuna Hospital in Surkhet, six out of seven specialist posts are empty, while Rukum West has three vacant posts out of four. Brish Bahadur Shahi, Chief of the Health Division at Karnali’s Ministry of Social Development, noted that geographical remoteness, poor transportation, low career advancement prospects, and limited opportunities for higher education cause doctors to consistently decline postings in these rural communities.
The state of medical care in Karnali exposes a stark gap between constitutional guarantees and practical reality. While the Constitution of Nepal enshrines healthcare as a fundamental right, mothers in Karnali continue to die from preventable childbirth complications, children suffer from treatable ailments like diarrhea, and injured patients are routinely carried for weeks in traditional bamboo baskets (doko) to reach basic care. Civil society activist Nabin Shahi pointed out that despite political transitions and federal promises that services would reach every village, the government has failed to mobilize healthcare personnel according to sanctioned posts, leaving the region acutely neglected.
According to health administrators, policy flaws and economic disincentives lie at the root of the crisis. Dr. Rabin Khadka, Director of the Provincial Health Directorate, explained that doctors can earn over 300,000 rupees per month in urban private sectors, whereas rural postings offer only a basic salary without adequate perks. Furthermore, the Provincial Public Service Commission has failed to conduct regular permanent recruitment, relying instead on temporary contract postings that doctors routinely reject. The government has also failed to approve sanctioned posts for eleventh-level General Practice (MDGP) doctors in district hospitals, and following the withdrawal of support programs like the Nick Simons Institute, rural surgical services have effectively ground to a halt.
Addressing this crisis requires decisive policy intervention from both federal and provincial authorities. Health experts and local advocates argue that the government must introduce a dedicated Karnali Allowance providing a 100 to 200 percent salary incentive, alongside free housing and family security for deployed specialists. Additionally, enforcing a strict legal mandate requiring doctors who specialize under government scholarships to serve their first three to five years in remote districts like Karnali, combined with regular permanent recruitment drives, is essential to transform these empty facilities into functional life-saving hospitals.
Karnali reports progress in economic and budgetary reforms
Karnali Province has shown recent improvements in its economic indicators, according to the provincial government. Chief Minister Yam Lal Kandel said his administration is prioritizing reforms in policy, implementation, and transparency to ensure more effective governance.
He highlighted improvements in budget expenditure, transparency in project selection, and priority-based policymaking. Kandel emphasized that the government is preparing infrastructure for budget implementation, selecting projects based on development needs rather than political influence, and allocating funds through a project bank. He also underlined a clear policy of not moving forward with projects lacking assured resources.
“Plans will no longer be chosen on the basis of political access, and the era of ‘planning without funding’ has ended,” Kandel said. He added that projects are now being taken to the tender stage on time, with measures in place to ensure their completion.
The provincial government has also strengthened its monitoring system to ensure transparency in expenditures and budget execution. This fiscal year, the administration has prioritized frugal spending, cutting unnecessary allowances, limiting formal events, and curbing wasteful activities—steps that Kandel said reflect the government’s commitment to financial discipline. Provincial Assembly member Daxina Shahi remarked that the current government is setting standards in planning, budget allocation, and public services.
Karnali, once criticized for failing to spend its budget, spent 65 percent in the last fiscal year—close to its target—compared to less than 60 percent in previous years despite setting an 80 percent spending goal.
Agriculture has also been placed at the center of economic policy. Kandel said agriculture is being developed not only as a livelihood but as the backbone of a self-reliant economy. The government is focusing on agricultural registration, concessional loans, seed and fertilizer supply, irrigation infrastructure, and strengthening cooperatives. He added that the government aims to end the narrative of politicians claiming sole credit for development projects.
Under new arrangements, all projects are approved by aligning recommendations from the Provincial Planning Commission, local government priorities, and ministerial agendas. This approach, officials say, will not only improve budget utilization rates but also increase the likelihood of project completion.
Minister for Physical Infrastructure Development Sher Bahadur Budha acknowledged that negligence by contractors has delayed several major projects in the past, but noted that legal action has been initiated against defaulters. He said the government aims to achieve significant improvements in capital expenditure this fiscal year.
Despite progress, challenges remain. Some projects still fail at the initial stage, remain incomplete, or face accountability issues from past unfinished works. Provincial Planning Commission member Dambar Rawal said that stronger evaluation, tracking, and monitoring systems are needed to ensure projects address people’s needs rather than political influence.
He added that the commission is working on balanced and regionally just planning, with a focus on self-reliant and inclusive economic growth—an approach that, according to him, will yield tangible results in the coming years.

