At nine at night in Nepal, a migrant worker in Qatar calls home. His wife tells him about the children and their day. Before they hang up, she mentions the school fees, and he promises to send the money with his next salary. He has spent three years abroad so his children can build a future at home without having to leave as he did.
There is a contradiction inside that hope. The education he is paying for may be preparing them to follow him.
More schooling and less learning
Nepal receives remittances equivalent to more than a quarter of its economy, among the highest shares in the world. These transfers help families cover daily expenses, repay debts and pay school fees. As household resources and educational aspirations have changed, a growing share of children has enrolled in private schools. Private schools accounted for 11.23 percent of total enrollment in 2000. By 2022, their share had reached 29.67 percent. This shift coincided with rising remittance income, which has helped some families afford paid schooling.
Economist Gary Becker’s theory of human capital helps explain this investment. Families weigh the cost of schooling against its expected future returns. If education promises better earnings and greater security, spending on it becomes worthwhile. Higher household income can make that investment possible. A migrant's sacrifice becomes a child's opportunity and Nepal appears to be converting foreign wages into skills at home.
But schooling and learning are not the same thing. Nepal’s national assessment of Grade 8 students found that mean mathematics scores fell from 500 to 483 between 2017 and 2020. Science scores dropped from 500 to 470. Only 32.1 percent of students achieved basic proficiency in mathematics, while 37.7 percent did so in science.
The contrast raises a question, not a conclusion. Private-school enrollment has grown while measured learning has weakened. Yet these figures do not establish that private schooling has failed or that remittances have caused learning to decline. The assessment period includes the pandemic and prolonged school closures, while national averages combine community and private schools serving households with different circumstances.
Nepal also lacks sufficiently comprehensive published evidence comparing learning across school types and household migration status. The country has expanded educational access without adequately establishing whether its growing investment is producing the knowledge and capabilities children need.
What a wage cannot buy
Economists describe a related difficulty through the principal-agent problem: the person financing an activity cannot always observe how it is carried out. In a migrant household, the problem is physical. Money can pay school fees. It cannot sit beside a child at the kitchen table and check the homework. The parent best placed to provide that supervision may be the same person whose absence made the remittance necessary.
The effects pull in opposite directions. Remittances can ease the cost of schooling, while parental absence can disrupt supervision and change how families allocate time and resources. Research on migration and education finds mixed effects, depending partly on who migrates, who remains at home and how care responsibilities change.
Money buys a seat in the classroom. It struggles to buy what happens once the child sits down in it.
A credential built to travel
Families invest in education for the opportunities it can provide and those opportunities are not equally valuable everywhere. When foreign study and employment offer better prospects than the domestic labour market, a qualification recognised abroad can become especially attractive. Its value lies partly in what it enables a student to do, not only in what they learn.
Economist Michael Spence showed how qualifications can signal ability to employers who cannot directly observe a worker’s productivity. But a credential can also have practical value because it satisfies the requirements of a foreign institution or employment pathway. A language qualification, for instance, can demonstrate a skill while opening access to further study or work abroad. For a family weighing its options, the question is not simply what a qualification teaches, but what opportunities it opens.
The scale of the overseas education pathway is substantial. Nepal issued 112,593 No Objection Certificates for study abroad in 2023/24, of which 34,731 were for Japan. In 2024/25, education-related payments abroad reached Rs 138.48bn, up from Rs 125.13bn the previous year. For comparison, the government allocated Rs 21.45bn to domestic higher education that year. These figures measure different things, but they show the scale of the money flowing towards overseas education. Between 2018/19 and mid-March 2024/25, estimates put overseas education spending at roughly Rs 493bn, excluding India.
These figures show the scale of the investment but not its eventual return. Some students will return with valuable skills; others will build their careers abroad. Nepal has limited evidence tracking these outcomes.
The butterfly effect
Follow one transfer through the system. A father’s wage pays for a private school, which wins paying families by selling English and test preparation. The child's credential is built to travel, and consultancies that earn their fee on placement teach what placement requires. The next wire goes toward a student visa. Each step is reasonable and no ministry designed any of it, yet millions of such choices quietly reorient a school system toward departure. A small act of love at one kitchen table becomes a national pattern.
Nepal did not invent this pattern. From the 1960s, the Philippines expanded private nursing colleges to prepare graduates for licensing exams recognized by American hospitals, and by one estimate more than half of its licensed nurses now work overseas while its own hospitals run short. The schools were never broken but were simply built for a different employer than the one at home.
What this means for Nepal
There is a serious counterargument. The prospect of migration can encourage people to acquire more education than they otherwise would. Some return with skills, experience and savings that benefit Nepal. Migration can produce brain gain as well as brain drain. But these gains should be measured, not assumed. Nepal needs better information about what children learn in different types of schools, how household migration affects their education and what happens to students after they study abroad. Who returns? What skills do they bring? Do they find productive work and does their education improve their earnings?
No education reform can, by itself, close the wage gap that encourages young Nepalis to leave. If the domestic economy offers fewer attractive opportunities, families will continue responding to the incentives before them. Yet the state can measure learning more carefully, track returning graduates and evaluate whether educational providers deliver the outcomes they promise.
Nobody designed this outcome. No ministry set out to prepare children for departure and no parent paying school fees intends to finance an exit. The pattern emerges from millions of families trying to secure a better future with the choices available to them.
The father in Qatar sends money so his children can learn and choose. His hope is sound. The question is whether Nepal can make that education valuable at home as well as abroad, so that leaving becomes a choice rather than the only convincing route to a better life.