Will Thapa unite Nepali Congress?

Gagan Kumar Thapa’s election as the president of the Nepali Congress (NC) presents both an opportunity and a formidable challenge for Nepal’s oldest democratic party. His emergence represents a potential break from the established political culture of seniority, factional bargaining, patronage, and personality-driven leadership that has defined the party since the restoration of democracy in 1990.

The political document he presented at the 15th General Convention articulates an ambition to transform the NC from an organization primarily concerned with elections, government positions, and internal power struggles into a member-driven, performance-oriented, and socially connected institution.

Thapa may have weakened the chronic factional structures that crippled the party over the last three decades by attracting a significant section of leaders previously aligned with Sher Bahadur Deuba.

However, he must still contend with entrenched interests, organizational inertia, electoral uncertainty, and the steep challenge of building public trust. His principal test will be translating his reformist political vision into institutional practices that endure beyond his personal leadership.

One of Thapa’s immediate advantages is the apparent weakening of the traditional factional structure within the NC. Several leaders who previously benefited from Deuba’s patronage have shifted toward Thapa, diminishing the organizational strength of the former establishment. Currently, no towering personality among the office bearers appears ready to challenge him or form a rival faction.

Nevertheless, the decline of Deuba’s faction does not automatically signal the end of factional politics. Factionalism in the Nepali Congress has historically been sustained by fierce competition for party positions, electoral tickets, ministerial appointments, and access to state resources. Eliminating these entrenched interests will be a herculean task.

Compounding this issue, Thapa already faces criticism for operating within a tight circle. Without broadening his working style and improving cadre accessibility, he will struggle to address these deep-seated problems. During the general convention, representatives expressed concern that the party might simply transition from Deuba-centered politics to Thapa-centered politics without altering its underlying structure.

At the same time, Thapa must keep a watchful eye on his own supporters, who frequently block the entry of the Deuba faction out of fear of losing their own positions. In several locations during the selection of convention representatives, Thapa’s loyalists refused to hold intra-party elections, effectively sidelining their rivals. If he is to build a truly unified and open institution, Thapa must insulate himself from his own party hardliners.

There is a strong sentiment among cadres that Thapa must demonstrate flexibility to accommodate Deuba and his loyalists. Furthermore, many former rivals joined Thapa in search of political opportunities rather than out of a shared commitment to his reform agenda. Few genuinely subscribe to his vision; many simply aligned with him after the Supreme Court validated his position. While expectations are high that he can revive the party's strength, injecting genuine reform into the NC remains an uphill battle.

Thapa’s political report acknowledges this structural problem, arguing that authority has become concentrated at the top while general members receive instructions rather than meaningful opportunities to participate in decision-making. The document explicitly rejects the idea that the party belongs to any single leader, office bearer, or faction.

This highlights a clear contradiction: Thapa needs sufficient authority to overcome resistance to reform, yet he must avoid using that authority to establish another personalized system. His true test will be whether he can institutionalize internal democracy even when it limits his own power.

Many party leaders note that, like Deuba, Thapa has shown intolerance toward internal dissent. Transparent candidate selection, genuine competition for leadership positions, enforceable term limits, and uniform disciplinary standards would provide far stronger evidence of reform than the mere disappearance of rival factions.

Although Deuba has lost some of his former political leverage, established leaders retain substantial influence across the country. They possess extensive personal networks, strong relationships with district and provincial leaders, deep experience in electoral mobilization, and control over local party structures.

These networks cannot be dismantled overnight, making it difficult to sideline senior leaders. A sizable presence of leaders and cadres continues to attend local conventions organized by the Deuba faction—a force fully capable of weakening the party’s foundation if alienated.

Thapa must reconcile two potentially conflicting objectives: respecting the contributions of senior leaders while preventing seniority from becoming an automatic entitlement to power. His report attempts to bridge this gap by advocating collaboration across five generations, honoring elders while rejecting hereditary political privileges and prioritizing merit, contribution, and accountability.

The upcoming local elections will serve as a crucial test of Thapa’s leadership, even if he does not view immediate electoral outcomes as the sole measure of success.

While the NC retains a widespread nationwide network, its historical legacy no longer guarantees public support. The rise of the Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP) reflects growing voter dissatisfaction with established political parties and their governance records.

If Thapa fails to unite the party, which is currently grappling with internal divisions, many local leaders are likely to join RSP in hopes of securing election tickets and winning seats. Moreover, if the party suffers significant losses in elections, it may struggle to regain public support and win the next local elections.

Thapa now faces a difficult strategic choice: prioritize short-term electoral gains through political alliances, or rebuild the independent identity of the Nepali Congress. His explicit opposition to pre-election alliances reflects the latter approach. His refusal to form coalition governments across seven provinces illustrates the practical costs of this stance. Such decisions risk driving rival political forces together, thereby weakening the NC.

RSP’s popularity remains intact, and communist parties are increasingly gravitating toward unity. If the NC remains divided, the Deuba faction could attempt to forge an electoral alliance with the CPN-UML to undermine Thapa’s leadership—a move that external forces might also encourage. Thapa’s stance is that the party can afford to lose some local government seats in the short term if it positions itself to perform significantly better in the next parliamentary elections. He appears largely unbothered by this risk, even after the party suffered a heavy defeat in the March 5 parliamentary elections under his leadership.

In his political document, Thapa emphasizes the urgent need to reconnect with the public. He acknowledges that the distance between the Congress and the general populace has widened due to power-centric politics, factionalism, and unequal access to opportunities.

However, identifying this gap is only the first step; fixing it requires more than just leadership changes. Citizens evaluate political parties through tangible experiences—public service delivery, employment opportunities, anti-corruption efforts, economic security, and overall governance.

Thapa’s political report offers a broad vision for party transformation that goes beyond short-term electoral strategy or leadership turnover. It seeks to redefine the relationship between party members, political leadership, broader society, and the state through five central principles: institutional democracy, performance-based politics, generational renewal, social engagement and accountable governance.

Implementing these principles, however, will be extraordinarily difficult. The central pillar of Thapa’s vision is the redistribution of authority within the party. He criticizes the top-heavy concentration of power and the tendency to treat members as mere campaign tools rather than active decision-makers. He proposes expanding direct member involvement in shaping policy, selecting candidates, and electing leaders.

The report also calls for regular, transparent membership registration and renewal, clear criteria for leadership positions, and reliable internal electoral processes. This represents an attempt to shift the foundation of party legitimacy from personal loyalty to institutional participation.

Under this proposed model, membership would confer both rights and responsibilities. Members would have structured avenues to express dissent, run for office, and contribute to policy formulation rather than being called upon solely during election cycles. Such reforms could strengthen internal democracy, make the party more responsive to local communities, and reduce reliance on established political patrons.

Another core feature of Thapa’s vision is replacing traditional patronage with measurable contributions. The report introduces written job descriptions for party positions, regular self-evaluations, performance reviews, and community service metrics to determine leadership responsibilities and candidate selection.

In a performance-driven system, party officials would be expected to demonstrate concrete achievements, public service records, and accountability before receiving further responsibilities or election tickets.

While Thapa has outlined an ambitious framework to remake the Nepali Congress, he faces steep obstacles. Public frustration with traditional political parties is at an all-time high.

The NC and other legacy parties seem hopeful that if the current government fails to deliver on its promises, voters will naturally return to them. However, that outcome is far from guaranteed. Even if the RSP's momentum slows, new political alternatives will inevitably emerge.

On a positive note, Thapa has successfully attracted younger demographics. Yet, youth support for the NC remains uncertain. Young voters are actively scrutinizing Thapa’s own track record as a lawmaker and party leader—particularly his performance since 2008. Whether his vision can survive internal resistance and regain the public's trust will define the future of both his leadership and the Nepali Congress.