Why Nepal’s new ambassadors need vision, not just programs

Kathmandu-- Nepal’s diplomatic engagements with India, China, and the United States require more than the continuation of existing projects, the implementation of past agreements, and the pursuit of routine bilateral exchanges.

 As Nepal enters a new political phase under the Balendra Shah-led government, its diplomatic representatives must demonstrate how they intend to advance long-term national interests amid changing regional and global power dynamics.

 The presentations made by the proposed ambassadors to these three key partners raise a fundamental question: are Nepal’s diplomatic appointments guided by a forward-looking strategic vision, or are they primarily focused on managing an existing administrative agenda?

The distinction between a vision and a program is central to effective diplomacy. Programs detail what an ambassador intends to do during a tenure, whereas a vision articulates what Nepal seeks to achieve, why those objectives matter, and how diplomatic engagement will accomplish them.

 Without such an overarching framework, an ambassador risks becoming a mere manager of routine bilateral affairs rather than a strategic representative capable of shaping their future direction. The presentations of the three nominees heavily emphasize ongoing projects, pending agreements, and familiar priorities.

 While these issues are important, they do not demonstrate how Nepal should position itself in a rapidly evolving international environment. For a nation situated between two rising powers and seeking a productive partnership with the United States, diplomacy cannot be confined to resolving individual matters. Nepal requires a coherent framework that connects economic development, national security, regional connectivity, technological cooperation, investment, trade diversification, and strategic autonomy. This lack of strategic depth is evident in the specific presentations delivered by the nominees.

The proposed ambassador to China, Kalyan Sharma, reportedly highlighted road construction, border openings, and the implementation of past agreements. Although vital for cross-border connectivity, these priorities represent only a fraction of what Nepal should pursue with Beijing. Given China's massive capabilities in renewable energy, digital technology, manufacturing, and industrial development, Nepal’s diplomatic focus should move beyond basic infrastructure to explore structural economic transformation.

 Similarly, the proposed ambassador to India, Nischal Nath Pandey, faced the challenge of articulating a modern vision for Nepal-India relations. Despite India’s expanding economy and growing global influence, the presentation gave insufficient attention to sensitive pending issues—such as the review of the 1950 Treaty of Peace and Friendship and unresolved border disputes—as well as practical strategies for reducing trade imbalances and integrating into India’s expanding industrial and technological supply chains.

A similar pattern emerged in the presentation of the proposed ambassador to the United States, Chiran Jung Thapa. While the nominee emphasized high-level visits, defense assistance, membership in international advisory bodies, and security cooperation involving the Indo-Pacific Command, these activities do not constitute a comprehensive strategy. Securing a visit or obtaining sectoral assistance is an operational outcome, whereas a strategic vision must explain how defense and political ties fit into Nepal’s broader national security framework, constitutional obligations, and non-aligned foreign policy. Defense cooperation, particularly in disaster response and peacekeeping, must be pursued transparently and with due regard for regional sensitivities.

Ultimately, foreign policy must directly serve national development and long-term stability. A strategic vision provides clear direction, prevents diplomacy from becoming purely reactive, and aligns international relations with domestic economic priorities. The parliamentary hearing process must therefore evolve beyond validating candidates who simply list ongoing projects or repeat established government slogans. Lawmakers should evaluate nominees on their strategic thinking, requiring them to articulate long-term objectives, navigate sensitive bilateral disputes, manage regional risks, and establish clear metrics for evaluating diplomatic success.

 Emphasizing continuity may offer short-term administrative ease, but without a distinct strategic vision, Nepal’s diplomatic representation will struggle to meet the challenges of a changing global landscape.